AL Exec: Damon Deserves 1-Year $3 Million

Steve Kornacki of Mlive.com interviewed an unnamed American League executive the other day who couldn’t believe Damon rejected a $14 million and $6 million offers from the Yankees.

“Sometimes, we ask for too much,” said the source, requesting anonymity. “Then, the smoke clears and you ask, ‘Where am I?’ And now, I can’t believe anybody is going to offer Damon more than the $14 million and $6 million the Yankees did.

“If you turn them down for that, you deserve one year for $3 million or whatever he is going to get. In February, teams have got guys in place. My feeling is that now he is going to be lucky to get whatever he gets. It’s still supply and demand in this game. And Johnny’s arrow is in the middle or going down.”

I can’t say I disagree with him. Damon and his agent Scott Boras seem to think that he doesn’t age and that the market is somehow beneath him. In reality teams aren’t looking to give multi-year deals to an outfielder who is destined to regress offensively this year.  Bobby Abreu and Hideki Matsui both signed small deals after leaving the Yankees, does Damon really think he’s so much better than both of them?

Of course, Boras knows better than the rest of us. According to him there are still a few teams discussing deals for the free agent.

“I still feel there is a quality market for Johnny Damon,” Boras says, “and I’m negotiating with a number of teams. There are three teams out there that if they don’t have Johnny Damon, they’re not winning the division. He’s the difference in these teams making the playoffs or not contending.”

Boras, presumably with a straight face is referring to the Braves, the Tigers, and his infamous mystery team. He even sounds pretty optimistic.

“I can never predict what will happen in February, but talent has no wristwatch,” Boras says. “There’s always room for difference-makers. Fans know that teams are 95% complete, but a guy like this can make a dramatic difference.”

Realistically it appears that the Tigers are the only team even remotely interested in Damon. And their insistence on a multi-year deal could be putting that in jeopardy.

So what do you think? Will Damon eventually fool a team, probably the Tigers, into giving him a multi-year deal? Or is he going to regret not resigning with the Yankees?

This entry was posted in Editorial and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to AL Exec: Damon Deserves 1-Year $3 Million

  1. Brian Burkhart says:

    What Damon "deserves" is of course a subjective thing. But I do agree that if any team goes to more than the $6 million the Yankees offered, I'd be shocked. Can Boras fleece the Tigers again? Seems unlikely considering that the Tigers traded a younger and better version of Johnny Damon, Curtis Granderson, to save $5.5 million.

  2. At this point if the Tigers are smart they'll make him a reasonable offer and just wait for him to accept it.

  3. Sean Serritella says:

    I just hope the Yankees don't regret not signing him.

  4. nyyankeefanforever says:

    Nice thing about having 27 rings, Sean, is never having to say you're sorry. We're better, younger, and healthier this year than last with another All-Star onboard in the outfield and the best rotation and pen in MLB. Check out "Joe's Job — The Ballad of Terry Francona"
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WvVZQnELQ9s

    Must-see for Yankee fans and whiny BoSoxers!

  5. Jeffrey says:

    The scout's reaction is an emotional one. Few are looking at this objectively.

    I do not bet against Boras. It may take time but Johnny is going to get his money, I believe.

  6. Leo says:

    I really do understand that Boras is trying to get the most monies for his clients and himself, But will Johnny be happy in Detroit? Where ever Damon goes I wish him the best of luck and as a Yankee fan I am sure gonna miss him. I just wish that they could some how re-sign him he is declining But he is still an above ave. Player and VERY SMART. Well whatever happens Good luck Johnny I already miss you.