Game 19: Seriously? Yanks' Lose to MLB-Worst O's

Thought this first series against the Baltimore Orioles would be a breeze? Perhaps not.

The Yankees fell short to the O’s 5-4, behind staff ace Kevin Millwood and to the dismay of a shaky Yankee bullpen.

The first inning and a half went quickly. Luke Scott led off the O’s second with a single to left, followed by a Ty Wiggington single and a walk to Nolan Reimold, loading the bases with one out. Phil Hughes proceeded to walk Cesar Izturis, handing the Orioles their first run. Hughes didn’t look as sharp around the zone as his previous two starts, although it was clear home plate umpire Wally Bell was keeping a consistent tight strike zone. In the third, Nick Swisher led off with a single, followed by a Randy Winn single. After a Derek Jeter groundout moved the runners to second and third, Brett Gardner smashed a grounder to third baseman Miguel Tejada, who took it in the chest and allowed the run to score. Jorge Posada led off the fourth with a home run onto Eutaw Street. Score after 4: Yankees 2, Orioles 1.

The game kept moving until the bottom of the sixth when Hughes set down the first two batters. At 109 pitches, Girardi pulled him for Boone Logan, who walked Luke Scott. After that batter, Girardi brought in David Robertson, who hit Ty Wiggington with a pitch, putting runners at first and second and two outs. Three straight singles from Ryan Hughes, Reimold and Izturis put the O’s up by two, 4-2. Alfredo Aceves worked the seventh and eighth, allowing an unearned run on a single to Cesar Izturis after a Jeter error started the inning. The Yanks’ went into the top of the ninth to face Alfredo Simon, who was making his season debut after Tommy John just a year ago. Swisher singled after a Curtis Granderson strikeout, and Nick Johnson followed with a walk. After a Jeter strikeout, Gardner reached on an error to short, which allowed a run to score. Mark Teixeira followed with an RBI single, leaving runners at the corners with two outs for Alex Rodriguez. The Orioles had him played perfectly up the middle, and won the game.

Final Score: Orioles 5, Yankees 4.

Game MVP: Cesar Izturis


  • Jeter: 0-5 (5-31 on road trip)
  • Teixeira: 1-3, RBI  2 BB
  • Granderson: 0-4, 3 K
  • Winn: 1-3, K
  • Hughes: 5.2 IP  2 H  1 ER  4 BB  2 K
  • Robertson: 0.1 IP  3 H  2 ER  1 K (L)
  • Aceves: 2 IP  2 H  1 R  BB  K
  • Millwood: 5.1 IP  5 H  2 ER  3 BB  5 K
  • Castillo: 1.2 IP  1 H  3 K (W)
  • Simon: 1 IP  2 H  2 R  BB  2 K (S)

Around the AL East:

-Boston: 2, Toronto: 1

-Tampa Bay: 8, Oakland: 6

Yankees Record: 12-7 (7-6 away)

This entry was posted in Game Summary and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Game 19: Seriously? Yanks' Lose to MLB-Worst O's

  1. smurfy says:

    Glad you noted Wally Bell's tight strikezone, Dan. I dunno about consistent, except yeah, he consistently called pitches on the right side of the plate, with lefties at bat, strikes when they were wide. But the heighth? Usually barely above the belt was the limit, but I think I saw a letter-high strike later. In the second, Phil walked Izturis after he had clearly struck him out with a fastball at the knees and down the middle.

    How could he establish command when nothing was a strike? Looked like Bell called strikes based on whether the pitch pleased him; he often turned then hesitated, unsettled whether to raise his right hand. On what authority or to what purpose does an umpire squeeze an unestablished pitcher?

  2. Mike S. says:

    The HBP by Robertson came on an 0-2 pitch with 2 out. One pitch away from getting out of the inning. One pitch that changed the course of the game.

  3. Jeffrey says:

    Robertson went to see Dr. Andrews for a “tight” elbow in the middle of September last year. Take a look at this article:

    Given his poor start, it will be worth watching Robertson’s elbow to see if it is still giving him problems.

    • I remember that story. Personally I think that D-Rob’s problems are a result of inconsistent use. I think if his elbow was bothering him we’d have seen a drop in velocity, but he’s right about where he was last season on average (2009: 91.8 mph AVG on FB, 2010: 91.7).

  4. theboogiedown says:

    I’m curious, any mereit to the notion that Tex should have looked at a pitch or two to see if Gardy could have gotten himself over to second? If Tex gets the same hit (I’m certainly NOT suggesting he would) Gardy scores and Yanks get another shot once tied.

Comments are closed.