Mark Teixeira's Collision: The 2 Sides to the Story

The Yankees lost in heartbreaking fashion last night as Joba Chamberlain gave up an 8th inning two-run home run that put the Angels ahead for good 6-4. It was, like all games against the Angels, a very tough and hard fought game.

As far as some of the Angels are concerned it was a little too hard fought. I’m talking about a third inning collision between Yankees first baseman Mark Teixeira and Angels’ backup catcher Bobby Wilson, who was playing in just his second game of the season.

What happened was, with Teixeira on second, Robinson Cano slapped a single to shallow right, Bobby Abreu got the ball in from right and an error made it a very close play at the plate, with Jorge Posada signaling for Teixeira to slide, he did one better – took out the catcher. The problem was that some of the Angels said it was unnecessary and thought it might have been retaliation for Teixeira getting hit by a pitch earlier in the inning.

“He gave him the plate. You can either slide there or take him out,” Torii Hunter said. “I thought it was a little too early in the game to take him out. If he slides, he’s safe regardless. I guess he was on a mission.”

“It was (upsetting). He can score easily. I don’t know,” Ervin Santana said. “Maybe he’s trying to hit us because I just hit him. The count was 1-1. I don’t mean to hit him.”

However, Teixeira saw things a little differently.

“As soon as I came around third I picked up (Jorge Posada) who was telling me to slide,” Teixeira said. “It was going to be a close play. I saw he was on the plate, but I saw he didn’t have the ball yet, so I started to get down and make my slide. As soon as he turned toward me, I figured he had the ball and in that instance, the only choice that I have is to lower my shoulder and try to knock the ball loose.”

“Bobby is a great kid,” Teixeira said. “Before the game, I told him, ‘Best of luck this year.’ I feel terrible that he got hurt, but it’s not about trying to hurt him; it’s about trying to knock the ball loose.”

Despite the fact that the Yankees and Angels players saw things differently, both managers, who are both former catchers themselves, said that it just comes with the territory.

“No doubt about it, Mark’s just trying to score,” Angels manager Mike Scioscia said. “Clean play.”

“Your job as a catcher is to block the plate and try to keep the run from scoring,” Joe Girardi said. “Sometimes you get run over. I’ve had my nose broke, I’ve had my shoulder separated; it’s all part of the game as a catcher.”

Of course, Wilson didn’t have the ball, even though he was blocking the plate, and he suffered a concussion and injured his ankle. It was a rough play and it is only natural that his teammates might suspect that something sinister happened. Teixeira though is a former Angel and a stand-up player not known for playing dirty whatsoever. Realistically this was probably not intentional, but we won’t know if the Angels truely believe that or not until he comes to bat this afternoon. Maybe they’ll plunk him, maybe they won’t.

We’ll find out what happens this afternoon.

This entry was posted in Editorial and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Mark Teixeira's Collision: The 2 Sides to the Story

  1. The only thing I have to say about this is, this is what happens when a guy without the ball blocks the plate. I don't really feel bad for him.

  2. Peter says:

    Teix did the right thing because Wilson was in the transition in catching to the tag but did lose ball. Teixeira wouldn't take it out on the 3rd catcher for the Angels.

  3. Ms Molly says:

    This is disgusting! He went in "shoulder high" to knock this new catcher out of the game. You announcers are so prejudiced for the Yankees it's also disgusting. Scioscia should have backed this young catcher but he caved in also. Go home, Yankees! Glad Teix isn't an Angel anymore..he needs some humility & caring, but he doesn't have it!

    • I'm so glad Teix isn't an Angel anymore either. Honestly, and I really don't think I'm being bias here, I can't think of many more humble superstars than Mark Teixeira.

  4. smurfy says:

    I would like to see the home plate collision avoided. That was a horrible crash, and I was relieved that he wasn't more seriously hurt, the way his head and neck snapped over by the impact.

    The rulebook forbids any defender to block any base.

    Besides getting plunked, there was a throw that got away at first early, and as Mark was carried by the play back into the baseline two, three running paces behind the bag, the hitter, Torii, ran straight into him, although he could probably have swerved.

    We oughta decide if this is a contact sport or not. And fie on the neighborhood play, and the runner has to slide for the bag only.