More Questionable Moves by Girardi

It’s April 26 and the Yankees have dropped their first series of the season, not bad. The problem is that for the second time in a week the team’s manager, Joe Girardi, has made a couple of questionable moves that may have cost the Yankees the game.

1st Questionable Move

The first one may be his insistence on using Marcus Thames as the starting left fielder when the Yankees face lefties. Thames has actually done a great job mashing lefties so far with a .500 average and a 1.523 OPS, but the problem is that his play in the field kind of negates his offensive production.

2nd Questionable Move

That move is debatable though. What is not debatable is that Girardi miss-handled the at bat in which Angels first baseman Kendry Morales teed off on Damaso Marte.

What happened was this, Girardi signaled for Marte to walk Morales. After one pitch, he called it off and nearly came out to replace Marte with reliever David Robertson. However, before he even made it out to the field he also abandoned that plan. Now Marte is left out on the mound having almost walked Morales and then was nearly taken out. He then throws a pair of balls before he unleashes a meatball that Morales put into the seats.

The problem here is that as a manager, whatever decision you make, you need to make it with conviction. Girardi didn’t do that though and he left Marte with a 1-0 disadvantage and not really knowing what he’s supposed to do. That’s not a recipe for success and it put the Yankees behind 8-4.


This team has a stacked lineup and a stacked rotation. One loss, or even two, is not going to kill their chances this year. It’s possible the Yankees would have lost one or both of those games anyways, especially last night’s thanks to Javier Vazquez’s poor performance, but like I said in the last post criticizing Girardi – he really has to learn from these situations because committing them in the playoffs could end up really costing them.

The toughest decision is going to be with Thames. Girardi has to decide if it’s worth sacrificing Brett Gardner’s defense for Thames’ bat. This decision, especially in the playoffs, could have huge implications.

About Rob Abruzzese

Rob Abruzzese created Bronx Baseball Daily in 2008 just before graduating from Brooklyn College. He currently serves BBD as its editor and works as a reporter at the Brooklyn Daily Eagle. Follow Rob on Twitter @RobAbruzzese.
This entry was posted in Editorial and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to More Questionable Moves by Girardi

  1. nyyank55 says:

    Girardi does it again. Say hello to the real “clueless Joe”. 3-0 count to Morales and he decides to pitch to him rather than walk him intentionally as he had previously thought to do only to change his mind. We are seeing again what was exposed during the playoffs and world series last year. He either over manages or can’t make a decision because he lacks conviction. I've seen it a couple of time already this year when he's thinking of making a move and is asking approval from the coaches on the bench. Who's the manager here? Aceves was on a roll why start playing match up? Dude, go with what’s working for a change. That is what this Joe lacks that the previous Joe had…gut instincts and the ability to read his players. All Girardi reads are statistics. I mean this guy hasn’t got 2 thoughts in his head to make 1 idea. That’s the real reason his contract hasn’t been extended yet. He’s on a short leash only he doesn’t know it yet. Why? Because he is CLUELESS.

Comments are closed.